MarioWiki:Proposals: Difference between revisions

I feel like we need to have a broader discussion on what criteria we even look for when categorizing subjects as siblings within the same "franchise" or "series". To me, it does not really matter how involved Shigeru Miyamoto is with a particular project because: (1) Miyamoto has a history of involving himself with a wide diversity of projects both within and outside of ''Mario'' just to provide development guidance or maintain brand integrity with external parties (like Illumination Studios); and (2) I generally feel like published works should be interpreted independently for their own criteria for classification. Nintendo did not always consider ''[[Super Mario Land]]'' a mainline ''Super Mario'' series game, a game that saw almost no involvement from Miyamoto, but I always considered it so because there are no objective reasons within the game itself for it to be excluded. It is nice to see that Nintendo themselves have come to that same perspective. Additionally, the ''[[Super Mario Bros. Encyclopedia]]'', in all languages, explicitly states that the remakes of mainline series games, like ''[[Super Mario All-Stars]]'' and ''[[Super Mario Advance]]'', are not literal parts of the ''Super Mario'' series (pp. 238 - 255; note the star key on 238). Offhand, I am inclined to think a separation like that is very silly. - [[User:Nintendo101|Nintendo101]] ([[User talk:Nintendo101|talk]]) 12:50, May 12, 2024 (EDT)

:Miyamoto's involvement has never been considered as a factor in anything at all to my knowledge, not sure why this proposal brought it up. Whole development teams for games can change while still being in the same series, e.g. [[Donkey Kong Country (series)|Donkey Kong Country]]. {{User:Hewer/sig}} 12:59, May 12, 2024 (EDT)

==Miscellaneous==

''None at the moment.''