2,111
edits
MarioWiki:Featured articles/N1/Super Mario Run: Difference between revisions
MarioWiki:Featured articles/N1/Super Mario Run (view source)
Revision as of 15:08, January 20, 2018
, 7 years ago→Oppose
mNo edit summary |
(→Oppose) |
||
| Line 14: | Line 14: | ||
#{{user|Toadette the Achiever}} Yeah, it's just a fan vote at worst. | #{{user|Toadette the Achiever}} Yeah, it's just a fan vote at worst. | ||
#<s>{{User|Baby Luigi}} I'm going to assume that this nomination was up because the author thinks it's actually a quality article and not because he hasn't read the rules at all and I'll jump in and provide feedback on what could be improved. For starters, the game modes section is missing very vital information. There's no Kingdom Builder and no World Tour descriptions at all. Some information and vital features such as the user's ability to insert their own music is omitted as well, and I haven't even played the game to notice that. The obstacles and Item and Objects section is just a list of items with no images nor description of them, forcing users to possibly sift through links to find the item they're actually looking for. The levels section under World Tour is just a simple list of levels when it could be better organized and presented (see how other Featured Articles list their levels, such as ''[[Donkey Kong Country]]'' and ''[[Mario Party: Star Rush]]''. With a game additionally receiving constant updates, it would benefit the article to have an Update history section similar to how ''[[Mario Kart 8]]'' does i.</s> | #<s>{{User|Baby Luigi}} I'm going to assume that this nomination was up because the author thinks it's actually a quality article and not because he hasn't read the rules at all and I'll jump in and provide feedback on what could be improved. For starters, the game modes section is missing very vital information. There's no Kingdom Builder and no World Tour descriptions at all. Some information and vital features such as the user's ability to insert their own music is omitted as well, and I haven't even played the game to notice that. The obstacles and Item and Objects section is just a list of items with no images nor description of them, forcing users to possibly sift through links to find the item they're actually looking for. The levels section under World Tour is just a simple list of levels when it could be better organized and presented (see how other Featured Articles list their levels, such as ''[[Donkey Kong Country]]'' and ''[[Mario Party: Star Rush]]''. With a game additionally receiving constant updates, it would benefit the article to have an Update history section similar to how ''[[Mario Kart 8]]'' does i.</s> | ||
#{{User|YoshiFlutterJump}} This does not qualify for featuring, and your vote is flawed anyways. Fan votes are not permitted. This is almost as ridiculous as [[MarioWiki:BJAODN/Unfeature/Yoshi's Island DS|this]]. Maybe this qualifies for BJAODN as well! | <s>#{{User|YoshiFlutterJump}} This does not qualify for featuring, and your vote is flawed anyways. Fan votes are not permitted. This is almost as ridiculous as [[MarioWiki:BJAODN/Unfeature/Yoshi's Island DS|this]]. Maybe this qualifies for BJAODN as well!</s> | ||
#{{User|Lcrossmk8}} Since everyone seems to be voting for this side, and since all the evidence seems to support this side, I am gonna vote here, thank you very much. Per all. By the way, a featured article is an article that can potentially be featured on the main page, and it doesn't have to do with how accessible it is on the main wiki, right? | #{{User|Lcrossmk8}} Since everyone seems to be voting for this side, and since all the evidence seems to support this side, I am gonna vote here, thank you very much. Per all. By the way, a featured article is an article that can potentially be featured on the main page, and it doesn't have to do with how accessible it is on the main wiki, right? | ||
#{{User|LuigiMaster123}} Per all. That is far from a good enough reason for this article to be featured. | #{{User|LuigiMaster123}} Per all. That is far from a good enough reason for this article to be featured. | ||