13,340
edits
Talk:Birdo: Difference between revisions
→Oppose
MarioComix (talk | contribs) (→Oppose) |
|||
| Line 417: | Line 417: | ||
#{{User|Ray Trace}} Per all. | #{{User|Ray Trace}} Per all. | ||
#{{User|Nintendo101}} I do not think I would be opposed to individual bosses receiving their own articles, but the people who make ''Super Mario'' games have never had unique reverence for [[:File:Top100DefuseorLose.png|the concept of an "individual."]] Yoshis are not quite in the same situation. | #{{User|Nintendo101}} I do not think I would be opposed to individual bosses receiving their own articles, but the people who make ''Super Mario'' games have never had unique reverence for [[:File:Top100DefuseorLose.png|the concept of an "individual."]] Yoshis are not quite in the same situation. | ||
#{{User|MarioComix}} Firstly, I believe there has been enough distinction between Birdo as a character and as a species, at least in their species debut in ''Mario Power Tennis'' (where Bowser almost gets kissed by a generic red Birdo as opposed to the obligatory pink Birdo, which serves no purpose other than to say "this is not the usual Birdo"), and this persisting across games shows a clear continuation of "Birdo as a species" compared to one-off instances of multiples of [[Donkey Kong Jr.]], [[Toadsworth]], [[Petey Piranha]], or [[King Bob-omb]], wherein they serve specific gameplay or minor cameo roles. But the main reason I support keeping it merged as one page for Birdo and her species as a whole is due to the same old pitfall [[#This_Birdo.27s_page_miss_all_informations_about_her_playable_appearance_in_Super_Mario_Strikers_and_Mario_Strikers_Charged.|as above]], where people looking for "Birdo in Mario Strikers" will come to character Birdo's page and be confused about the lack of information from the first two ''Strikers'' games. So for '''ease of use''', it's better to keep all of Birdo and Birdos' appearances on one page. | |||
===Comments=== | ===Comments=== | ||