Talk:5-Volt: Difference between revisions
m (→Comments) |
|||
| Line 39: | Line 39: | ||
Reversinator's right. Also, that image shows the name of the organization, not the organization. But when I see a character, I mean, come on! If you see someone in real life, it means he/she exists 100 percent. But when you hear about someone there is maybe 90 percent he/she exists! Right?{{User:Mr bones/sig}} | Reversinator's right. Also, that image shows the name of the organization, not the organization. But when I see a character, I mean, come on! If you see someone in real life, it means he/she exists 100 percent. But when you hear about someone there is maybe 90 percent he/she exists! Right?{{User:Mr bones/sig}} | ||
Everyone seems bent to insist that she is just an implied character, but I hardly think that this is true. She appears with a physical form in the game and she talks directly. I think that is enough to make her more than an implied character. I mean, imagine this: If there were a convenient lightbulb everywhere she appears, we would get to see her face, and nobody would question that she isn't an implied character. I don't think we should put someone on the list of implied characters just because the lightening is bad. - {{User:Edofenrir/sig}} 14:52, 16 August 2010 (UTC) | |||
Revision as of 09:52, August 16, 2010
Merge 5-Volt into List of Implied Characters
|
This talk page section contains an unresolved talk page proposal. Please try to help and resolve the issue by voting or leaving a comment. |
Current time: Saturday, November 23, 2024, 15:10 GMT
This is ridiculous. How is this noteworthy of an article if its only been implied and that the only thing seen of her is her shadow? I say merge into that. The image thing is near impossible and its stubbiness is hard to get rid of.
Proposer: Booderdash (talk)
Deadline: August 14, 2010 24:00 GMT
Extended: August 21, 2010 24:00
Support
- Booderdash (talk) Per me.
- Zero777 (talk) I am Zero! Per Booderdash. Zero signing out.
- Mario4Ever (talk) A silhouette is not a sufficient image for a character that is not naturally a silhouette (i.e. Dark characters in Super Paper Mario). Therefore, 5-Volt is not technically seen in-game and is thus an implied character. Per proposal.
- LeftyGreenMario (talk) Silhouette or not, she is still implied. Per all.
- Baby Mario Bloops (talk) - Silhouette doesn't proof that it is not implied. For example, Rosalina's family appeared in her storybook, yet they are implied.
- Walkazo (talk) - Per Baby Mario Bloops.
- Mario jc (talk) Per all.
- Tomz123 (talk) Per all.
- BabyLuigiOnFire (talk) Per all, especially Mario4Ever
Oppose
- Glowsquid (talk) She "appears" in more than one game and her sillouhette is seen at the Game Over screen of Touched!. When I made the Implied pages, it really was to get rid of off-hand mentions in flavor text that wouldn't matter again (ex:Old Man Skoo).
- Reversinator (talk) 5-Volt appears twice, in two separate games. One is with a silouhette of her, and another shows just her legs, but that proves that she isn't implied.
- Bloc Partier (talk) - Per all. She appears. She's not implied.
- GalacticPetey (talk) Per Glowsquid
- MrConcreteDonkey (talk) Per all.
- FourPaperHeroes (talk) Per all.
- Grandy02 (talk) Just because she isn't fully seen, she isn't just implied. She actually appears (we can't see all of her, but at least we see a part of her body at all), has a little role in 9-Volt's story and even has a few speaking lines. 5-Volt isn't less notable than other minor WarioWare characters.
- Edofenrir (talk) - She isn't just seen. The image on the article shows her talking directly to another character. Implied characters don't talk like that; If they do, they are not implied.
- Mr bones (talk) What? Implied? How can she be implied when she's seen??? A silhouette of her and her legs are seen. Per all!
Comments
Where is she seen in the game? Since it says shes only a shadow so then we can't upload an image for it. 
I hardly see a justification in people's reasons that a silouhette is not enough. I'd like to know why it doesn't count. Plus in another game we see 5-Volt, not silouhetted. It was just her legs, but that proves that she isn't just implied.
The preceding unsigned comment was added by Reversinator (talk).
- In my vote, I said that a silhouette is not enough for characters that are not naturally silhouettes. If 9-Volt was a silhouette, it would be, since he would be a silhouette son of a silhouette. The same holds true for Dark characters in Super Paper Mario. Are you seriously considering uploading a pair of legs to represent 5-Volt in the article? By the way, make sure to sign your comment or something so I know to whom I am speaking. Mario4Ever (talk)
It doesn't matter if theres a picture of it. List of Implied Organizations also has pictures.
- Organizations and characters are different. If somebody shows a logo for an organization, there's no chance it's real. But when you see a character, there's no chance that he/she's implied. Hello, I'm Time Turner.
Reversinator's right. Also, that image shows the name of the organization, not the organization. But when I see a character, I mean, come on! If you see someone in real life, it means he/she exists 100 percent. But when you hear about someone there is maybe 90 percent he/she exists! Right?
Count Bonsula I need blood...
Everyone seems bent to insist that she is just an implied character, but I hardly think that this is true. She appears with a physical form in the game and she talks directly. I think that is enough to make her more than an implied character. I mean, imagine this: If there were a convenient lightbulb everywhere she appears, we would get to see her face, and nobody would question that she isn't an implied character. I don't think we should put someone on the list of implied characters just because the lightening is bad. - 
Gabumon(talk) 14:52, 16 August 2010 (UTC)
