MarioWiki:Featured articles/N1/Boo

From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search

"Boo" was nominated for featured article status at 18:45, 26 December 2008. If the nomination does not pass by 18:45, 24 February 2009, it will be considered failed.

Boo

Support

  1. Boo is a good article will lots of information and not to long. RedBoo64 (talk)
  2. Boo is a famous enemy with a page that is not too short, not too long, and it has lotsa info.GameMaster (talk)
  3. Boo should be a feature article its well writen with good pics.MarioPartyFanactic77 (talk)
  4. Boo is a well written article and deserves to be feautured, He rocks! Commander Buzz (talk)
  5. Deserves to be Featured. Dry Paratroopa (talk)
  6. Mario64fanatic (talk) Boo should be a featured article because of all the info on Boo and still being an article that's not to long to read. Also Boo is cool!
  7. Super Mario Bros. (talk) Per all. The article is good, written well.
  8. This is a good article, contains lots of information and a decent amount of links. 188seth (talk)
  9. This is an awesome article, It has lots of info and good pics.Yuiy (talk)
  10. Per all Marioguy1 (talk)
  11. Per All SpriteYoshi (talk)
  12. Personally I think that even though the page has a few problems, they could be easily fixed, and the article itself is great. -Doopliss rocks
  13. How could you not nominate something as cute as Boo? --Commander Lightning (talk)
  14. Why not, boo is a great character, especially in the spin-offs; Article passes FA requirements Baby Mario Bloops (talk)
  15. Boo is a good article. Nuff' said. Ohforf3 (talk)
  16. Boo is a wonderful article no matter what anyone else says!!! g.narron (talk)

Oppose

  1. In its current state, the article is not fit to be featured. Almost every section needs some help with grammar, size, and formatting. Also, the "The Appearance of a Boo" section either needs deletion or improvement. The lead at the beginning of the article also needs major improvement. Bloc Partier (talk)
  2. Urm, isn't Yoshi's Island DS supposed to be near the beginning? Also Super Mario World2:Yoshi's Island doesn't say ALL the boos that appear in the game. Also NSMB section needs more work. Super mario fan (talk)
  3. The History section needs a lot of work Dark Lakitu 789 (talk)
  4. I agree with Bloc Partier. This article has a TON of errors. Just look around. DON'T SUPPORT IT JUST BECAUSE IT LOOKS LONG OR YOU JUST LIKE BOO We might end up with a featured article with too many spelling errors...Fawfulfury65 (talk)
  5. Oh. My. God. WWWWWHHHHHYYYYYYYYYY TTTHHHHEEEEEE HEEEEEELLLLL ARE THERE SO MANY FAN VOTES?!?!?! This is a very erroneous article with many mistakes that need to be fixed before it gets even close to being a featured article. Electrobomber (talk)
  6. BabyLuigiOnFire (talk) Some parts of the history section needs a lot of work.
  7. Shyster66 (talk) There are tons of mistakes. The Yoshi Island artical has two sections!
  8. LeftyGreenMario (talk) There are a lot of grammar mistakes in this article. Second, the appearances aren't listed chronologically. Actually, a lot of sections needs to be improved. Sorry, but this article has a long way before becoming featured.

Comments

I want the Boo article to be featured! Boo is so cute! How could you not come to like and agree to publishing this article for featuring? All I have to state is,PUBLISH THE BOO ARTICLE AS FEATURED! WHO'S WITH ME?!

You aren't supposed to feature an article just because it's character is cute -_- I like Boo, too, but this article could still get some improvement. Fawfulfury65 (talk)

Ok THERE ARE TOO MANY FAN VOTES!!! Why can't we vote to remove support votes? Half of them are fan votes that should go. Fawfulfury65 (talk)

Can you prove they are fan-votes? Marioguy1 (talk)
Actually I just realized that only two were fan votes o_0. The last two supports are both fan votes. They don't mention why this is a great article, but in seems like they say that just because they like Boo. Also, g.narron's vote simply calls this a "wonderful article" but doesn't state the reason on why. Dry Paratroopa's vote just says "Deserves to be featured", but why does it deserve to be featured? I really think those votes should be removed. Fawfulfury65 (talk)

Well, as those 2 last votes you mentioned DO mention the article, and they say the article is great, they cant be removed. BTW, are sigs allowed here? Tucayo (talk)

@Tucayo: Then why did you remove them? No they are not as per my proposal. @Fawfulfury65: I agree with you, many of these are fan votes, why don't you make a proposal allowing users to propose support votes be removed if' an admin agrees with them (E.g. Two user votes, at least 1 admin vote). Marioguy1 (talk)
Retrieved from "https://www.mariowiki.com/index.php?title=MarioWiki:Featured_articles/N1/Boo&oldid=680683"