Talk:Big Blue Boo

This talk page or section has a conflict or question that needs to be answered. Please try to help and resolve the issue by leaving a comment.

Title

The SMW Player's Guide mostly describes him as Big Boo, but he's listed as Big Blue Boo in the enemies list. Is that enough to remove the conjecture tag? --Toadstool Forever 03:54, 23 March 2007 (EDT)

In the game itself, it calls him "The Big Boo" ^Plumber 12:57, 1 April 2007 (EDT)

Should this be called "The Big Boo", because the game calls him that. ^Plumber 15:26, 1 April 2007 (EDT)

No. It is fine the way it is. Para Yoshi ^Wahoo! 15:29, 1 April 2007 (EDT)

This article is meant to distinguish this boss Big Boo from the other Big Boos of Super Mario World. I think we should vote on it. -- Son of Suns

I think there should just be a sub section of Big Boo in the article about this.

Vote

Support Merge

1. ^Plumber
2. 
   Sorry, but I am Confused – I agree, the Big Blue Boo is barely a different species from the Big Boo with the only difference being... it's blue. I mean come on, its not even officially named!
3. Gofer
4. Elias5891 With the other Big Boos from the ghost houses being classified on the Big Boo page, this one should too. The only difference is his color and status as a sub-boss.
5. Xzelion^ETC

Oppose Merge

1. Totally. A fan of Yoshi | Here
2. In terms of game mechanics, this is a unique creature. The boss Big Boo isn't shy, is intangible, is vulnerable to blocks, and he's a level boss. The big blue Boo will hide if you look at him, Mario can touch him, he's invulnerable to blocks (AFAICT), and he's a common enemy. They look different, act different, and have different roles. If you merge these two, you might as well merge all the Yoshi's Island bosses into their common counterparts, since they're just bigger versions of common enemies.--Toadstool Forever 16:17, 9 April 2007 (EDT)
3. Aipom
4. Para Yoshi ^Wahoo! - Yeah… anyway…
5. Uh... I agree with Toadstool Forever. Yeah.
   ~ Luigi hc

Comments

I will merge or not merge this article in one week, depending on vote tallies. -- Son of Suns

The votes are tied. I cannot take any action. I will give this vote another week. -- Son of Suns

That ridicoulous, Big Blue Boo is just a Boo that happen to be blue. The “he act different in game mechanic.“ argument don't work.Should we make an article about SMD Wiggler?I mean he's green and he's a boss, he must have his own article!And what about creating an article about Super Mario World Goomba?They are thouger in that game and they look different!The article Chukster was merged with Pianta because they were only different in term of game mechanic.Why Big Blue Boo should be any different? Gofer

Yeah, just because he's weak against something else doesn't mean it's an entirely different species. Exactly, look at the Chuckster article.
I am Confused 13:47, 22 April 2007 (EDT)