Talk:The Goodwill Ambassador

Merge article into Cackletta

Template:SettledTPP DON'T MERGE 1-7

The Goodwill Ambassador doesn't appear as a separate character in the game, and there's no indication she even existed other than as an identity made by Cackletta. I suggest this be merged into the Cackletta article because of that.

Proposer: Superchao (talk)
Deadline: February 14, 2013, 23:59 GMT

Support

1. Superchao (talk) Per proposal.

Oppose

1. YoshiKong (talk) Per Marshal Dan Troop's comment here.
2. ThePremiumYoshi (talk) - Per Marshal Dan Troop's argument on the proposal YoshiKong mentioned; besides, if we were to merge this article with Cackletta, that page would have more cruft than it already has.
3. Mario4Ever (talk) Per YoshiKong.
4. King Pikante (talk) Per YoshiKong.
5. RandomYoshi (talk) — Per YoshiKong.
6. Toad85 (talk) Per Troop and YoshiKong.
7. Sonic98 (talk) Per YoshiKong.

Merge to Cackletta

This talk page section contains an unresolved talk page proposal. Please try to help and resolve the issue by voting or leaving a comment.

Current time: Friday, November 22, 2024, 21:32 GMT

Yes I see the proposal directly above this one, but the way that one went was comparing a disguise to a transformation. While the Black Cat was Princess Shokora, the cat played a bigger and more important role in the game while this is just Cackletta in disguise as a part of a plan she came up with. I believe this should be merged cause The Goodwill Ambassador is just a disguise at will while the Black Cat is a transformation.

Proposer: Tails777 (talk)
Deadline: July 19, 2014, 23:59 GMT

Support

1. Tails777 (talk) Cackletta and the Goodwill Ambassador are more alike to Luigi and Cassanova Koopa rather than Shokora and the Black Cat.
2. Ninelevendo (talk) A wilful disguise used for two seconds that's based on Lady Lima doesn't deserve an article. Mr. L was a forced disguise that was a different character. Gold Mario was merely a Powered-Up Mario, this article is merely a disguised character.
3. Vommack (talk) Per both.
4. Ghost Jam (talk) Per all.
5. Walkazo (talk) - Makes sense. Per Tails777.

Oppose

1. Sonic98 (talk) The sentence had already been issued. They are two completely different characters. It makes no sense to return on a proposal already rejected in the past. Would make sense if we would have more news on that character (and for the same reason they are against the proposed Gold Mario).

Comments

Seeing as this relates to Gold Mario (character), in terms of what exactly we are talking about, I'm wondering if there's an actual standard for articles like this. - 17:42, 5 July 2014 (EDT)