MarioWiki:Featured articles/Unfeature/N1/Rosalina

Rosalina

Remove Featured Article Status

1. Bazooka Mario (talk) I think Rosalina has a few major expansion-related problems that's holding this article back. One thing Rosalina definitely lacks is a background section, where I think should outline the events in Rosalina's Storybook; it's already mentioned in one sentence in the intro paragraphs, but not explored enough. The first section, on Super Mario Galaxy, is disappointing. Mario's article explains Rosalina's role in more detail, not only mentioning the beginning scene with Rosalina, but also the later cutscenes after the scientifically bogus explosion where Rosalina has a talk with Mario. Additionally, the section doesn't cover the true ending of the game, when Mario collects all 120 Power Stars. The article suffers from image clutter, which leaves behind a lot of blank space, but that's not difficult to fix. The Mario Party series can be incorporated into one section rather than be split into one liners. I wish Puzzle & Dragons: Super Mario Bros. Edition went into a little more detail about Rosalina since it's all meaningless numbers and stats to me, and besides, doesn't she have individual stats? The article does list it, although vaguely. Super Mario-Kun needs to be incorporated into the main history section. Finally, Rosalina needs a section on Super Mario Maker, but I'll give her a pass since the game is recently released. Rosalina's general information section is not the best, especially her clothing section, which has too much detail. There is also a unnecessarily separated subsection on her motorbike outfit. Rosalina's development section can probably be moved to the beginning of the article, similar to the one in Mario's article, although there isn't really a lot of information on it in the first place without going into boring description. Rosalina's personality and traits is not great either. Again, it can use an expansion from her storybook, but I think it can use more analysis from her speech and general demeanor, with examples. The relationships needs to deduct something from all the interactions with those Lumas. The merchandise section is particularly small, although I'm not sure it should be scrapped or not because Rosalina doesn't have much merchandising to begin with. Finally, Rosalina's profiles and stats section needs to summarize Rosalina's abilities and stats in paragraph format, maybe explaining her bio several times. Rosalina's article has several problems, mostly writing, expansion, and presentation issues, which I feel shouldn't allow her to be featured in that state.
2. Watcher of Game (talk) There's also the constant problems with pointless and subjective edits. I cannot tell you how many times someone has written "Rosalina looks like Elsa" in the Trivia section. I feel like if the article wasn't featured, we might not have so many unnecessary edits. Plus, without so many dumb changes, the article may be feature-worthy once more.

Removal of Support/Oppose Votes

Watcher of Game

1. Time Turner (talk) The amount of inane edits that an article gets has no bearing on whether or not it should be featured.
2. Bazooka Mario (talk) Per.
3. Roy Koopa (talk) Agreed, edits and featured status have nothing to do with each other.

Comments

I've merged the motorbike gear section and added Mario Maker info. I might try and improve it otherwise if nobody else wants to. The Pyro Guy (talk)

I've already started working on this article; I've already added a background section for starters. We could do a collab, Pyro Guy, if you want. Ray Trace^(T|C) 15:25, 13 October 2015 (EDT)

Yeah, I expected Baby Luigi to work on this. Mario^-HOHO! (Talk / Stalk) 16:00, 13 October 2015 (EDT)

A collab sounds great. Lets see, I could do the Mario Party and Galaxy parts, maybe some other bits too. That sound okay? The Pyro Guy (talk)

I'll expand her personality section. Ray Trace^(T|C) 16:49, 13 October 2015 (EDT)

The article looks good now.

(talk|contribs) 10:48, 16 October 2015 (EDT)

No, work still needs to get done. Ray Trace^(T|C) 15:34, 16 October 2015 (EDT)

Yup, it still has some problems left. Mario^-HOHO! (Talk / Stalk) 16:35, 16 October 2015 (EDT)

Watcher of Game: The article being high-traffic and thus a space to dump low-quality edits has no bearing on its status as featured or not. Mario^-HOHO! (Talk / Stalk) 16:35, 16 October 2015 (EDT)

yeah, you might need to reconsider that before I'll vote to remove your support. Ray Trace^(T|C) 16:42, 16 October 2015 (EDT)