MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive/41

Block on wiki = block on forum

VETOED BY THE ADMINISTRATORS
The wiki administration and forum administration operate independently of each other and have different rules which are not mutually applicable. A ban on the wiki does not equate to a ban on the forum unless the user has broken the rules on both venues and vice versa.

(not sure if this belongs in Changes or Miscellaneous; please move if necessary)
Normally, when a user gets blocked on the wiki, nothing happens to their forum account if they have one. Now that most people have both wiki and forum accounts, it should be considered that if a user does something stupid that gets him/her blocked on the wiki, he/she might go straight to the forum and complain about it (which isn't allowed), or do the same thing he/she did on the wiki in the forum, so therefore maybe this policy should be introduced.

Proposer: Lord Bowser (talk)
Deadline: August 10, 2013, 23:59 GMT.

Ban on both only when permabanned on wiki

1. Pwwnd123 (talk) Sounds fair to me.

Ban on both in all instances for same amount of time

1. Lord Bowser (talk) Per proposal.

Ban only on wiki (do nothing)

1. Yoshi876 (talk) I think it'd be better to go for a case-by-case standard for something like this. If the user was trolling the wiki, then sure a ban on the forum as well would probably be the best course of action seeing as they'll likely do the same on the forum. However, if it's something like adding false information repeatedly or using edit summaries in a non-constructive manner then I think it'd be pretty mean to bar them for all corners of the wiki.
2. 'Shroom64 (talk) Per Yoshi876; if someone's not doing anything wrong on the forum they shouldn't be banned there for malicious wiki activity.

Comments

You forgot a "Do Nothing" section, which would probably be best as there are instances of people being blocked on forum and not on wiki. If the user gets themselves blocked on the wiki, but still acts in a gracious manner on the forums then I don't see why they should be banned there. Yoshi876 (talk)

The "ban only on wiki" section is pretty much the "do nothing" section; sorry if that wasn't clear. LB (talk • edits • forum) 03:39, 3 August 2014 (EDT)

Okay, thanks :) Yoshi876 (talk)

It would probably be better if there was something like "Ban if they were using excessive language on the wiki", because that's the only way I see it working. - 04:37, 3 August 2014 (EDT)

Or like I said, trolling, especially seeing as there is no rule against swearing on the forum so it'd be stupid to ban them because of that. Yoshi876 (talk)

I meant excessive excessive swearing on the wiki. - 07:34, 3 August 2014 (EDT)

Still no rule against it on the forum, so it'd be pretty mean to ban them from that for it. Only way swearing would get banned from both is through flaming. Yoshi876 (talk)

I guess I should of just said flaming. But the "Do nothing" still doesn't work, as it says "Only on Wiki", when they could of been banned from the forums. - 08:23, 3 August 2014 (EDT)

I think that kind of discussion should be left to the admins themselves. You should have PMed an admin telling him the idea, and left the final decision to them instead of jumping into an open proposal.--

05:28, 3 August 2014 (EDT)