Talk:Playable character
Delete page
Perhaps this could be made into a list form, or preferably merged with List of characters by game with an asterisk convention to show they are playable.
Shokora (talk · edits) 03:14, August 21, 2020 (EDT)
But in this list it shows in how many games each one of these playable characters is playable so far, the first game in which each one of them is playable and the latest game in which each one of them is playable. The problem is that not in all article there is a proper table that shows their appearances clearly. List of characters by game is a list of characters by their first appearance. Orhoshmand (talk) 03:37, August 21, 2020 (EDT)
- I honestly don't think this article is necessary either.
Nightwicked Bowser 
- Agreed this list is unnecessary, the category page serves this purpose. If someone wants to add or check the number of playable appearances they've made and their earliest/latest ones, or check the playable characters in a game, they do it on the individual articles or follow the subcategory links, because this list will become way too long and be filled with many one-off appearances.
- I don't think merging to List of characters by game would work either since that only lists characters debuting in each game, so not all playable characters would be indicated.
Mario JC 07:33, August 21, 2020 (EDT)
Unlike the category, this list includes only the most common playable characters. I also request to add the information wherever there is a question mark. Wherever there is a question mark there should be an informaion that I can't write myself. Orhoshmand (talk) 08:37, August 21, 2020 (EDT)
- I still think it's unnecessary because as I said, this information can go on the individual articles. Mario JC 08:48, August 21, 2020 (EDT)
- There are two conditions to include a character in this list:
- The character appeared as a playable character in at least 20 games so far.
- The character appeared as a playable character in at least 10 new games from the last 5 years.
The preceding unsigned comment was added by Orhoshmand (talk).
- I really don't see the point of this page. If a proper definition of playable character is needed, it can just go on MarioWiki:Glossary. Including every playable character on this page is essentially what the category is for, number of playable appearances can just go on the other character's pages, and if we went with the guidelines you listed above, it would be very hard to keep an eye on, particularly the second one- would a character get removed from the list if we went over the five-year mark for their tenth most recent playable appearance? Other things would need to be questioned as well, like properly deciding which artworks are used, or we're going to end up with a very inconsistent set over time. The exact guidelines for things like this would also need to be established with some community agreement as well. I just this page just seems to be trying to solve a problem that isn't there and the upkeep would be more trouble than it's worth. BBQ Turtle (talk) 10:56, August 21, 2020 (EDT)
- Agreed. There is no point to this page.
(T|C) 11:05, August 21, 2020 (EDT)
- Absolutely. There would additionally be the problem of what truly constitutes a "playable" appearance. Doc von Schmeltwick (talk) 11:08, August 21, 2020 (EDT)
- This article is intended to show the most common playable characters in Mario franchise, in how many games each one of them appeared as a playable character, and what is the first and the latest appearance of each character as a playable character. The artworks are just copied from the infobox in the article of each character. Orhoshmand (talk) 11:21, August 21, 2020 (EDT)
- Like others have said, that can be shown on each individual article, and most of them also have a table with all their appearances, and even indicates which ones they are playable in. Nightwicked Bowser
- Like others have said, that can be shown on each individual article, and most of them also have a table with all their appearances, and even indicates which ones they are playable in.
- Agreed. There is no point to this page.
- I really don't see the point of this page. If a proper definition of playable character is needed, it can just go on MarioWiki:Glossary. Including every playable character on this page is essentially what the category is for, number of playable appearances can just go on the other character's pages, and if we went with the guidelines you listed above, it would be very hard to keep an eye on, particularly the second one- would a character get removed from the list if we went over the five-year mark for their tenth most recent playable appearance? Other things would need to be questioned as well, like properly deciding which artworks are used, or we're going to end up with a very inconsistent set over time. The exact guidelines for things like this would also need to be established with some community agreement as well. I just this page just seems to be trying to solve a problem that isn't there and the upkeep would be more trouble than it's worth. BBQ Turtle (talk) 10:56, August 21, 2020 (EDT)
This is not the type of page that falls in our coverage. The redirect to the Glossary, as it is currently, works better. We do not need a list of every playable character when the categories exist, and the two conditions you outlined are completely arbitrary. 
11:32, August 21, 2020 (EDT)
